Skip to content

Replacing storage heaters: new heaters or an air-to-air heat pump?

An air-to-air heat pump gives far cheaper heat than any storage heater. A storage heater turns 1 kWh of electricity into 1 kWh of heat, so even at a cheap Economy 7 night rate of about 14p, each kWh of heat costs about 14p. A modern split system that heats delivers the same kWh for about 5p to 7.5p on a standard tariff, and heats when you want it, evenings included.

Retired couple with mugs of tea in a bright 1970s London flat on a snowy winter morning, a white wall-mounted air conditioning unit heating the room
per kWh of heat, storage heater at best
13.99p
per kWh of heat, air-to-air heat pump
5.1p to 7.5p
certified, Daikin Perfera 2.5 kW
SCOP 5.2
two rooms on one outdoor unit
From £3,650
On this page9 sections

Storage heater replacement: the short answer

You have two honest choices. New high heat retention storage heaters keep your Economy 7 setup and waste less heat. An air-to-air heat pump, split air conditioning that heats, costs more to fit but gives each kWh of heat for half the price or less, and cools in summer too.

Neither heats water, so an Economy 7 immersion cylinder carries on as before.

Why storage heaters run out in the evening

A storage heater charges a heavy core overnight on cheap off-peak electricity, then lets the heat out through the next day. Economy 7 gives a lower rate for 7 hours at night, so all the day's heat has to be bought in those hours.

Older heaters leak heat all morning, often while you're out, so the core is nearly empty when you get home. Citizens Advice notes that boost heat uses electricity at the more expensive peak price.

Storage heater running costs on Economy 7 against a heat pump

Cost per kWh of heat in the room. Economy 7 rates: Octopus Flexible Economy 7, London, a tariff that follows the cap. Single rate: Ofgem cap GB average, 1 October to 31 December 2026, Direct Debit.

Heat sourceElectricity priceEfficiencyCost per kWh of heat
Storage heater, charged overnight13.99p (E7 night)1 to 113.99p, at best
Storage heater boost or panel heater by day33.11p (E7 day)1 to 133.11p
Air-to-air heat pump, premium unit26.32p (single rate)SCOP 5.25.1p
Air-to-air heat pump, value unit26.32p (single rate)SCOP 4.65.7p
Air-to-air heat pump, cautious real-world figure26.32p (single rate)SCOP 3.57.5p

Unit prices only. The storage heater figure assumes every stored kWh is used when wanted, which old heaters rarely manage.

Why a heat pump wins on cost

A heat pump moves heat from the outside air, giving several kWh of heat for each kWh of electricity. That ratio over a season is the SCOP. Daikin's Perfera FTXM25A, a 2.5 kW wall unit, is certified by Eurovent at 5.2. Value units sit around 4.6, and our winter heating study uses 3.5 to allow for real homes.

One catch: on Economy 7, the heat pump's daytime electricity is billed at the dearer day rate. If you replace every storage heater, ask your supplier whether a single-rate tariff now suits you better.

The honest alternative: high heat retention storage heaters

High heat retention heaters, such as the Dimplex Quantum, have a better insulated core and automatic controls, so more of the overnight charge lasts into the evening. Citizens Advice calls them the most efficient storage heaters.

They suit you if you can't get consent for an outdoor unit or want to keep your tariff. But they still turn 1 kWh of electricity into 1 kWh of heat, so heat costs the same per kWh. You just waste less.

How a storage heater replacement works with us

  1. Free survey

    We check heat loss, the outdoor unit position and pipe routes.

  2. Fixed quote

    Prices start from £1,850 for one room, £3,650 for two, £5,100 for three and £7,500 for four on one outdoor unit. Your written quote after the survey is the fixed price.

  3. Consent

    In a flat, get the freeholder's written consent before we fit.

  4. Fitting

    We fit the units, commission them and show you the controls. Ask at the survey about disconnecting the old heaters.

Replacing storage heaters: questions

What is the best replacement for storage heaters?

For running costs, an air-to-air heat pump: about 5p to 7.5p per kWh of heat at the current cap, against about 14p from a storage heater at best. Without an outdoor unit, high heat retention heaters are next best.

Why do my storage heaters run out of heat in the evening?

They charge overnight and leak heat through the day, so the core is nearly empty by evening. Boost then costs the peak rate.

Are storage heaters cheap to run on Economy 7?

Cheaper than daytime electric heating, but not cheap. At Octopus's London night rate every kWh of heat costs 13.99p, and boost at the 33.11p day rate costs more than twice that.

Are high heat retention storage heaters worth it?

They hold heat into the evening better, so you rely less on boost. They don't make heat cheaper per kWh, so they won't match a heat pump.

Can I replace storage heaters in a leasehold flat?

Usually, yes. An outdoor unit normally needs the freeholder's written consent and sometimes planning permission.

Is there a grant to replace storage heaters with an air-to-air heat pump?

Not one you can claim yet. A £2,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant for air-to-air exists in law, but it can't be claimed until installers can be MCS certified for air-to-air.

Sources

5
  1. Ofgem, energy price cap unit rates and standing charges
  2. Octopus Energy, public tariff API: Flexible Octopus Economy 7 day and night rates
  3. Eurovent Certification, Daikin FTXM25A and RXM25A heating figures
  4. Citizens Advice, using storage heaters and immersion heaters
  5. Dimplex, Quantum RF high heat retention storage heater